Chidambaram seeks Vodafone's views on tax issue in writing: Official

 
Finance Minister P Chidambaram has asked UK-based Vodafone Group, which is facing a tax liability of over Rs 11,200 crore in India, to give its view on the long-pending matter in writing, a senior official said on Tuesday.

"Finance Minister P Chidambaram has asked Vodafone to give its view on the tax matter in writing," said the Finance Ministry official.

Vodafone Group Plc's Chief Executive Vittorio Colao had met Chidambaram last week.

The British telecom major is facing a tax liability of over Rs 11,200 crore, along with interest, on its 2007 acquisition of Honk Kong-based Hutchison Whampoa's stake in Indian telecom major Hutchison Essar.

The government had proposed a non-binding conciliation to the telecom major to sort out the tax dispute.

Although the company had been expressing its keenness to reach an amicable settlement with regard to the tax issue, there were differences over the rules under which the dispute should be taken up.

While the British telecom major has indicated its preference to conciliation under the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, India has proposed settlement under the Indian Arbitration and Conciliation Act.

The Supreme Court last year had ruled in Vodafone's favour, saying the British company was not liable to pay any tax over its 2007 acquisition of mobile phone assets in India.

The government, however, changed the rules to enable it to make retroactive tax claims on already-concluded deals, drawing criticism from global business groups.

Following amendment to the I-T Act of 1961 last year, the Income Tax Department had issued a letter in January to Vodafone International Holdings BV stating that the company was required to pay the tax.

Vodafone replied, saying that they DID not owe anything to the Indian Government. Vodafone earlier wanted to take India to international arbitration but later offered conciliation on the issue.

Vodafone to invest $3 billion over 2 years in India

 
Notwithstanding its nearly Rs 12,000 crore tax dispute with the government, Vodafone plans to invest $3 billion in the next two years that will be deployed for network expansion in rural areas.

Vodafone global CEO Vittorio Colao, however, declined to go into the details of the "positive" meeting he had with Finance Minister P Chidambaram on Tuesday on the tax issue.

"I am grateful to the Finance Minister for giving me time to meet him. It is good to have a dialogue between an enterprise and the policy maker. It is positive," Colao said, but he parried a question whether Vodafone would be willing to pay up around Rs 11,200 crore income tax demand.

He said Vodafone was incredibly positive about India not only from the business point of view but otherwise too.

Colao said in the next two years, Vodafone will invest $3 billion in India.

"Our organic or real investment into the country is a significant $3 billion in two years... is the right decision," he said making it clear that the tax dispute with the government is in no way upsetting their plans for India.

He said he believed in India and also the data in it.

After Germany, India is a priority market for Vodafone for long-term investments in technology and data, he added.

He said the proposed $3 billion investment excludes spectrum fee the company has to pay.

"First, India has an opportunity for growth because of population and other factors. We will be long-term players. I am happy we are here for long-term investment. I am not here for 4 years but for 20 years and more," Colao said.

To a question, he said the tax issue will not affect Vodafone's hiring plans and investment and developing network in India.

The British telecom major is facing a tax liability of over Rs 11,200 crore, along with interest, on its 2007 acquisition of Honk Kong-based Hutchison Whampoa's stake in India's telecom major, Hutchison Essar.

Vodafone bets big on India 3G, to invest Rs 7,100 cr

 
Vodafone has drawn up ambitious plans to invest 700 million pound ( about  Rs 7,100 crore) in India during the next 2- 3 years mainly on rolling out 3G networks.

This amount will be in addition to  Rs 4,000- Rs 6,000 crore annual investments the company has been making in recent years, Vodafone India CEO Marten Pieters said on Tuesday.

The investment will be part of the cash- rich British company's Project Spring under which the Vodafone Group will invest 7 billion pound by March 2016, to establish stronger network and service differentiation in major global markets.

"The Indian investment is about 10 per cent of pound 7 billion in the next 2- 3 years. It depends also on what is available. The investment will be above the normal level of investment we would have done so it's like a catch up investment," Pieters said.

Riding on a strong growth in data usage and voice calls, Vodafone India said it has posted 13.5 per cent jump in revenue at  Rs 20,476.3 crore for the first half ( April- September period) of 2012- 13.

The company had logged Rs 17,581.3 crore in revenue during the same period in the last fiscal.

Pieters said, India has become the third largest contributor to the UK- based Vodafone Group's services revenues.

" We are also focused on growing the use of mobile Internet. Our data continues to contribute strongly to business, accounts for 9 per cent of service revenue in Q2, 2013- 14 fiscal," said Pieters.

He said most of the subscribers in India would use  Internet via mobile phones but the company doesn't have 3G spectrum in all the circles.

"We will try to get spectrum in all the circles next year. We count on pending approval for spectrum trading and the fresh 2100 Mhz auction in 2014," he pointed out.

On revenue growth, he said it is driven by hardening of rates, exponential growth in data and good subscriber base. "These, however, were partially offset by the effect of seasonality and regulatory changes," he added.

"The service revenue has grown 13.5 per cent to Rs 18,481 crore during the 6- month period from  Rs 16,282.6 crore in the corresponding period last fiscal, but our data revenue has grown much faster at 76.5 per cent. The data growth has been driven by high smartphones usage, he added.

Vodafone India's operating profit or EBITDA ( earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization) improved by 30.6 per cent to  Rs 6,519.1 crore in H1, 2013- 14, compared to  Rs 4,993 crore in the same period of last fiscal.

Pieters said the environment in the country is more positive these days as the regulatory clarity is emerging. However, at the same time he pointed out that that all is still not fine on the regulatory front.

Meanwhile, Vodafone Group chief Vittorio Colao at a meeting in London on Tuesday said the company will only consider an IPO in India once the $ 2- billion tax dispute is resolved.

"We don't have to do it… because we don't need the money. We need to resolve the tax issue first," said Colao.

Colao added that there was " no real change" to discussions on the tax dispute. " We have had talks and continue to have talks. It's complicated and honestly, we have to see where it goes."

Vodafone posted a 13.5% jump in revenue at  Rs 20,476.3 cr for the first half of 2012- 13.

Telecom tariffs may go up every year: Vodafone MD

India's second largest telecom operator Vodafone expects phone call and other mobile services rates to go up every year, indicating that low tariff regime may not be sustainable any longer for the industry.

"We have lower tariffs for 18 years against inflation of 8-9 per cent per year. Now, can you do that forever? No you can't," Vodafone India Managing Director and Chief Executive Officer Marten Pieters said in an interview.

"So the point has come where lowest has been seen, we will have to increase our tariffs every year depending on cost levels," he said.

He said that like everyone else, the telecom industry too has to increase the prices.

Last month, the company increased 2G mobile Internet rates along with two other players,  Bharti Airtel and Idea Cellular, in the range of 25-30 per cent.

Peiters said that going forward 2G data rates and 3G data rates will be at same level indicating a further hike in 2G mobile Internet rates.

"We started 6-7 times high tariff rate when we opened up 3G network. It is now back to 1.5 to 1.6 times of 2G data rates. It over time will come together. But it can't come over time just by lowering 3G tariff, it needs to also see increase of 2G tariffs. Once it is equal, it doesn't matter to customer anymore," Pieters said.

The company's competitors such as Reliance Communications and Aircel have, meanwhile, reduced 3G mobile Internet rates to bring them on par with 2G mobile Internet rates.

Pieters said that industry will have to work to create efficiency in the network to handle increasing load.

"My assumption is that our price increase will always be lower than inflation but you can't of-course forever keep lowering your prices, its impossible," he added.

In a bid to remain profitable, leading telecom operators have increased rates of special tariff vouchers and reduced free minutes usage.

Bharti Airtel too has said recently that the current tariffs in the country "are at absolutely unsustainable levels".

Pieters said however that despite the tariff hikes India still has the lowest tariffs in the world.

"India has still the lowest tariffs in the world. I think there is only one country which is coming closer, which is China. The only difference being that in China, there are only three operators, they are very profitable and they invested last year USD 55 billion in telecom infrastructure. We did USD 5 billion, so what's better for the country," he added.